A Tale of Tumult: The SEC Charges against Binance and Coinbase


Summary: In the dynamic realm of cryptocurrencies, two titans once held sway: Binance and Coinbase. Their platforms allowed millions across the globe to trade digital currencies, their influence reaching every corner of the crypto market. But as their power grew, so did the scrutiny they faced. In the early June of 2023, the Securities and Exchange Commission ...

In the dynamic realm of cryptocurrencies, two titans once held sway: Binance and Coinbase. Their platforms allowed millions across the globe to trade digital currencies, their influence reaching every corner of the crypto market. But as their power grew, so did the scrutiny they faced.

Untitled-design-2-1260x709.pngIn the early June of 2023, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), a formidable force in the financial world, turned its gaze upon these two crypto behemoths. Alleging that both Coinbase and Binance had violated rules requiring them to register as exchanges and be overseen by the federal agency, the SEC launched lawsuits against them. More specifically, the SEC alleged that Coinbase traded at least 13 crypto assets that were, in fact, securities and should have been registered with regulators before they were issued. These assets included notable tokens such as Solana, Cardano, and Polygon.

The charges were based on the premise that because Coinbase made these tokens available for trading and the SEC alleged they are securities, the company was required to register as an exchange, brokerage, and clearing agency. This lawsuit was the culmination of a two-year effort by SEC Chair Gary Gensler to shift his agency’s enforcement strategy in crypto from the issuers of individual tokens to the online platforms where those assets are traded.

The crypto world watched, holding its breath as the charges were announced. Companies like Coinbase had made it possible for customers to transfer dollars from their bank accounts to buy or sell cryptocurrencies, a significant departure from the days when prospective traders had to find each other using message boards or similarly clunky forums, agree on a price, and hope their counterparty was honest.

The fallout was immediate. Share prices for Coinbase tumbled by 17% in early trading, the tremors echoing throughout the crypto market. Binance, too, felt the sting, their reputation sullied by the legal onslaught. The actions against these titans, once thought invincible, sent a clear signal: the age of unregulated crypto trading was coming to an end.

Tuesday’s lawsuit was another significant move toward regulating the entire crypto industry. The SEC’s strategy had centered on using its enforcement division to subdue the industry and show why its regulations apply to crypto activities. The SEC was now waging battles with some of crypto’s biggest market participants, including Coinbase, Binance, and another crypto exchange, Gemini.

The impact on the crypto industry was profound. The SEC's charges sent shockwaves through the market, leading to increased volatility and uncertainty. Crypto exchanges, in response to these developments, began scrutinizing their practices, anxious to avoid the fate of Binance and Coinbase.

For the average investor, the charges led to a wave of anxiety. The future of crypto, once seen as a new frontier of financial freedom, now seemed uncertain. Many worried about the next Bitcoin bull market, with the potential for increased regulation casting a shadow over the industry's future growth.

Despite the increasing regulatory pressure, Coinbase launched a legal and public-relations campaign in response, telling lawmakers that the SEC was making a power play to oversee a new technology that doesn’t fit within its rules. Some Republican House lawmakers have been sympathetic to Coinbase’s concerns, and the company's chief legal officer, Paul Grewal, was scheduled to testify before the House Agriculture Committee on whether some crypto assets should be treated as commodities and not securities.

Gensler has warned that crypto exchanges need to register with his agency. He has frequently said that such firms handle several functions that securities exchanges can’t, including holding customer assets and clearing transactions. His solution was for crypto exchanges to separate their order-execution, brokerage, and clearing functions, similar to how Wall Street operates, with stock exchanges, brokers and clearing firms functioning as separate businesses that follow rules tailored to their operations and risks.

Crypto exchanges have resisted Gensler’s demand to remake themselves in the image of Wall Street. They also say many tokens aren’t securities and that coin developers can’t provide financial disclosures like public companies do. That hasn’t persuaded Gensler or his enforcement staff. “Without that proper disclosure, the public can’t answer a question as to whether it’s just…counterfeiting or a scam or something else,” Gensler said Tuesday on CNBC.


However, amidst the turbulence, some voices in the industry expressed a sense of cautious optimism. Aaron Kaplan, co-CEO and co-founder of Prometheum Inc., saw the SEC's action as a meaningful shift towards regulated market infrastructure for crypto, which he believed would ultimately help the industry move forward. He told Coindesk that the competitive landscape would look different, but that it would result in a net benefit for U.S. investors and should allow innovation to thrive.

Others, such as Richard Mico, the U.S. CEO and Chief Legal Officer of Banxa, noted the negative impact of the ongoing lack of regulatory clarity. In an interview with Coindesk, He warned that the current situation could drive digital asset ventures away from the United States to friendlier jurisdictions, potentially depriving the U.S. of jobs and innovation at home1.

Dan Raju, CEO of fintech company Tradier, told Blockworks that greater and clearer crypto regulation by the SEC was long overdue. He believed that while these changes might impact crypto prices in the short run, they would create retail confidence in crypto in the long term.

Despite the challenges, these industry insiders expressed a belief in the resilience and innovative potential of the crypto industry. Their views encapsulated a sense of cautious optimism, a belief that despite the regulatory hurdles, the industry could adapt and grow.

However, not all views were positive. Kristin Smith of The Blockchain Association was unimpressed with the latest salvo from the SEC, stating that the regulator doesn’t “make the law – it only makes accusations”.

As the industry grapples with the fallout from the SEC's charges, the future of crypto remains uncertain. What is certain, however, is that the coming years will be a defining period for the crypto industry, and the world will be watching closely.

Author: BitpushNews Susan Feng

  • Mainnet Web3+AI Party Set to Illuminate New York City on September 20th 4 days ago
  • ARK Invest Acquires Rize ETF, Paving the Way for European Expansion 4 days ago
  • Balancer's Front-End Suffers Attack Resulting in $238,000 Loss 4 days ago
  • 【The Road to Innovation in Cryptocurrency】DAI's stumbling road of exploration 5 days ago
  • Could Crypto ETFs Catalyze the Next Bull Market? 10 days ago
  • You need to login to comment.